I do a lot of reading on here and not much posting. But I thought I'd add my two cents.
I never thought I would, but I agree with the senator, It's not really related to the original topic as Gerard has already pointed out he does it to drum up business and he isn't a newbie. But condemnation of newbies charging less from the vets does sound like self-preservation. It's unrealistic for a newbie to ask for the same money as a vet because at the end of the day they aren't going to provide the same service, so who wouldn't just hire the vet and get a better result? I'm not talking about intentionally undercutting or ridiculous low rates, just LOWER professional LABOUR rates for those with less experience.
I think it also comes down to the production, It's illogical to expect a professional wage on a low budget student or out of the directors pocket film. If you don't want to help at a reduced rate then don't, no one will blame you, but I don't see the point in scrutinising those that will.
There is no internships or working your way up in a TV network anymore (or at least not over here), so how else do you gain experience?
As for shaming people into submission, I was unaware this was 1940's German. If you need to shame someone into sharing your beliefs and find a need to correct their "moral compass" it sounds like a weak belief and a fear of change. That's not to say I disagree with the belief itself I just don't see people as raised nails that need to be hammered down.
There's no right, there's no wrong, there's only popular opinion. - 12 Monkeys
As for the OP, originally I thought it was in the same league as a PA with a H4N on the end of a boom. I didn't think in any way, shape or form I would be defending it and I'm still not sure I agree with it, but I think the haircut analogy works. He's catering for a niche that already exists in the market, not creating a rival within the market. I'm not sure I would ever use that method of advertisement, but it's a creative industry and we are creative people. it's his business to represent the way he see's fit. I'm sure some people don't like me using a skull as my logo but that's the way I run my business.