Jump to content

Wisycom or lectrosonics


chrisyking

Recommended Posts

So I'm trying to decide between a wisycom kit at £3.2k or a lectrosonics at 3.5k.

 

Both kits are dual receiver and two transmitters.

 

So my question is, how important is 100mW?

 

1) The wisycoms in the UK can't do 100mW 

2) lectrosonics can do 100mW

3) wisycom can work with sennheiser tx which can be 100mW

4) wisycom are currently wideband, lectrosonics aren't

 

So, the question is, do I wait for the wideband lectrosonics or just go get the wisycom kit?

 

What say you?

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I rarely bump my SMQV's beyond 50mw finding that after scanning and setting on a clear frequency, the range is fine for the majority of situations I'm recording. There have been occasions when 100mw and even 250mw has been helpful, but transmit power wasn't the main reason I chose Lectrosonics for my wireless sets. One consideration is for the times you'll want to tune into another recordist's transmitter when working the same shoot. The proximity to service is another consideration when sending something to the mother ship and how long it will take back and forth. The wide band L series Lectro sets are expected in the wild sooner than later and are 50 to 100mw selectable, but again to say in my experience 50mw has been more than sufficient so for me anyway transmit power isn't the main consideration.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

CK: " So my question is, how important is 100mW?... So, the question is, do I wait for the wideband lectrosonics or just go get the wisycom kit? "

somewhat, but it depends; and that is up to you.

" Anyone have any info on lectrosonics new range? Can't see anything on the site. "

it has been frequently discussed here... so the question is: where have you been..?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both are very good, it is a personnal choice ! I choose Wisy because I am travelling a lot and the wide radioband is very helpfull. On documentaries most of the times I set the transmitters to 10mW power, without any problems. On feature on 50mW. Wisy receiver is capable to receive Sennheiser 5000 series and Evolution, Audio Limited and Shure. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So I'm trying to decide between a wisycom kit at £3.2k or a lectrosonics at 3.5k.

Both kits are dual receiver and two transmitters.

So my question is, how important is 100mW?

1) The wisycoms in the UK can't do 100mW

2) lectrosonics can do 100mW

3) wisycom can work with sennheiser tx which can be 100mW

4) wisycom are currently wideband, lectrosonics aren't

So, the question is, do I wait for the wideband lectrosonics or just go get the wisycom kit?

What say you?

Where in the UK are you finding Wisy for that price? The 'special deal' expired some time ago.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a friend who ordered an extra set he doesn't need.

Well then, you are getting a premium wideband system at a bonus price.

Whilst I don't know prices on future manufacturers wideband releases, they are unlikely to be cheaper than the reduced price Wisy and most likely more. Full price Wisy are VERY expensive.

Worth considering if the TX are the units without limiters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

O.K. thanks, so it's basically down to the 50mW question then.... hmm.....

Power isn't everything. This is predominately a US frequented forum and while many US mixers seem uncomfortable with our UK limit of 50mw I've found my own Lectro don't see much of an improvement in range at 100mw when using the 'rubber duckies'.

250mw can dramatically improve range for long walk and talks but it's not a magical cure. I had two TX out the other day at that power and whilst one of them provided startling range the other was fritzing all over the shop until it was within 25 yards of me. Good frequency coordination and better aerials on the RX work wonders.

I have no scientific proof to back it up, but in my opinion our new CH38 is far more problematic than other 'illegal' channels.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The  two systems have been recently tested by experienced users from my company, and were also measured .

From a technical point of view, their quality is very  similar, their range is also very similar .

The Wisycom receiver is a true dual diversity receiver, the Lectro is not but during the tests no difference in range could be detected between the two .

For the audio quality, both are excellent, but the Wisycom was slightly more natural sounding .

 

The main difference between Wisycom and Lectrosonics is the very wideband for Wisycom and the much narrower band for Lectro .

You really don't have to worry about the 50 mW power compared to 100 mW, the range difference is extremely low .

The most important aspect to decide if you go for Wisy or for Lectro is the big difference in bandwidth .

A wideband system such as the Wysicom is a guarantee that it can be used nearly everywheree in the world and in nearly any conditions (such as a lot of frequency users at the same place at the same time) .

My opinion is that if the price difference is not so big, the Wisycom is probably the best choice .

 

Hope this helps, and sorry for my bad English .

 

Eric D

Belgian Radio-Television

Link to comment
Share on other sites

eric: " receiver is a true dual diversity receiver "

the other is untrue ??

sorry, but they are both true diversity receivers, but use different forms of diversity, and as you noticed: " no difference in range could be detected between the two . "

" the big difference in bandwidth . " and in reality, there are pros and cons  to that...(just as comparing Yagi to LPDA antennae (sic)

 

so which did you buy..?

Edited by studiomprd
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did a simple range test of when I was considering upgrading from my Lectro UM200 (100mW) & to a LMa (50mW).  The 50 vs 100mW was a concern I was fretting about.  They both cut out at about the same distance and my mind was made up, upgraded to the LMa & sold the UM200.

 

YMMV, but I felt I wasn't losing anything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...